Like most people who were watching tv last night, I was intrigued to hear about the death of Bin Laden. The news broke in the middle of the Simpsons, and apparently was deemed more important than me finding out what happened in the marriage between Selma and Fat Tony. I will never know if the marriage was for real, or if Marge and Selma managed to repair the family bonds. However the Simpsons is not what I am blogging about, so it must have been the right decision to leave me hanging on that front and fill me in on the changing state of terrorism.
I didn’t really know how to react at first. My first thoughts were, that’s good, but surely there is another one just like him that will fill in his place and continue in the same manner. Does this actually make any difference in our daily life? Will I now be able to walk through airport security with my shoes on? Are those suffering under terrorist rule now free to live without fear? I doubt it.
As I watched though, I became more intrigued by the reaction of people than by the news itself. I began to feel embarrassed and ashamed to be part of a so called civilized society as I watched people dance around like Monty Python characters at a witch burning.
The world is probably safer without Bin Laden in it, and a part of me is relieved that he is no longer around, I even think it is probably the best realistic outcome. Am I pleased about it though, am I happy that this happened? Certainly not.
While this is being hailed as a huge success, to me this represents one of the greatest failures by mankind in my lifetime.I am not referring to the operation, but rather to the entire approach to terrorism.
Sept 11, 2001 I was at Chicago O’Hare airport waiting with some friends who were flying out that day. We were evacuated, and went back to my friends place to watch the events unfold. Like most people I was horrified, angry, confused. I then watched as Bush declared war against no-one in particular and was saddened by each lost life in a war that could never be won.
The FBI has admited that the evidence linking Bin Laden to the 911 attacks was vague. I remember him sending a message that he was proud of the people who did it and was pleased about it, it then took him years to even say he had anything to do with it – a confession that could easily be pride or politics. Yet we have always been led to believe it was him and no-one else.
The ultimate goal in the fight against terrorism was always to see terrorists dead, to me, that is the ultimate failure, and to see people dancing in celebration when it happened is shameful.
Ezekiel 33:11 As surely as I live, declares the Sovereign Lord I take no pleasure in the death of the wicked, but rather that they turn from their ways and live.
As with most “holy”wars, I believe God would be ashamed of us, and even angry that we claimed his right for vengeance as our own.
Do I think Bin Laden was ever going to change? No. Do I think killing him is the best solution for the world? Yes. Do I take pleasure in it? May it never be. May we be saddened that it came to this, may we be embarrassed that negotiations and discussions were replaced by violence like a bully in a school yard who couldn’t think of a better way to answer the smart kid.
I don’t have solutions, and if I was in Obama’s situation, I probably would have done the same thing.
The world might be a marginally safer place, but is it a better place?
The cost of thousands of lives from both sides, more youth in the east growing up to resent the west, more anger, more violence, more sadness. What did we learn, where do we go from here? Now that goal is achieved, is the war now won, or do we just move on to the next guy on the list and kill him too? What could be achieved if we threw those same billions of dollars we throw at war in to rebuilding broken relationships. What could be achieved if we supported counselors and diplomats to the extent we support soldiers and weapons manufacturers.
What of a child who has had his father killed by the US military, what does that child do? Too often, they will hold a resentment against the west and if you were ever looking for reasons why people would join the taliban – there it is. What if that same child was looked after, cared for, had his family house rebuilt and was helped in to a life of hope?
This event represents 10 years of failure in war, and an ongoing failure of the human race to reconcile religion in a non-violent manner. I know that we were never realistically going to reconcile things with Bin Laden, but we shouldn’t be proud that our failure has been “resolved” by a death.
Bin Laden did not face a trial, we all know he was guilty, but by denying him basic human rights, we lower ourselves to his standard and say to the world and to the taliban that it is o.k. to bypass human rights if you really believe in something. Bin Laden was murdered, and our peers were dancing in the street to celebrate it.
I hope that as the initial reaction dies down, people have had a chance to consider what this really means how much this reveals the depravity of our nature. When we dance in celebration at the murder of a murderer – what have we become?
We are better off without him, he was guilty, but let’s not feel like we have achieved anything until we actually have.
Filed under: Thoughts | 4 Comments »